Harold Innis once described Canadians as little more than “hewers of wood and drawers of water” — a nation defined by abundant natural resources waiting to be taken. Today we can see how that offhand remark glosses over the real debates about what energy resources mean for Canada. Ongoing conversations about decarbonization, climate justice, and Indigenous sovereignty, among other issues, expose the tangled and often conflicting views that shape Canadian energy landscapes. Some make the case for continuing hydrocarbon extraction as a practical "bridge" toward a low-carbon future, while others call for a faster and more radical socio-technical transition. Between these poles lie many possible pathways, each carrying its own uncertainties and risks. Such debates usually play out in abstract institutional arenas or at the community level, yet their political, economic, and environmental consequences reach across the country and through the wider global energy system. This course examines current debates over Canada’s energy future through the lens of landscape architecture. Built around the format of a formal debate — affirmative, negative, and rebuttal — it traces the historical transformation of landscapes driven by energy extraction and asks students to analyze and imagine possible energy futures through design.
Fieldwork
February 2020. Yellow stakes stand as a sign of opposition to the Site C Dam and the flooding of the Peace River Valley that would follow. Photographed at the Bear Flat farm of Ken and Arlene Boon.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does ARC452 cover?
ARC452 — “Hewers of Wood, Drawers of Water”: Designing Canadian Energy Futures — is a course that looks at current debates over Canada’s energy future through landscape architecture. It examines how landscapes have historically been transformed in the pursuit of energy resources and asks students to analyze and imagine possible energy futures through design.
When and where was the course taught?
It was offered in 2021 at the University of Toronto’s Daniels Faculty of Architecture, Landscape, and Design.
How is the course organized?
The course follows the format of a formal debate — affirmative, negative, and rebuttal — using it as a framework for weighing competing views on Canadian energy landscapes.
Which themes does the course explore?
Topics include decarbonization, climate justice, Indigenous sovereignty, hydrocarbon extraction framed as a “bridge” to a low-carbon future, and demands for a faster socio-technical transition — along with the uncertainties and risks of the pathways in between.
Why is the course titled “Hewers of Wood, Drawers of Water”?
The title draws on Harold Innis’s remark that Canadians are mere “hewers of wood and drawers of water.” The course uses that characterization to open up debates about the role of energy resources in Canada and the complex, often contradictory perspectives that shape Canadian energy landscapes.
Across the term, students move between historical analysis and speculative design, treating energy landscapes as both evidence of past decisions and sites of future possibility. The debate format gives each position room to be argued and tested, so that competing claims about extraction, transition, and sovereignty can be examined side by side rather than reduced to a single answer.